Balkan
Witness
Home


BALKAN WITNESS

Articles on the Kosovo and Bosnia Conflicts

Deniers of Serbia's War Crimes:
Edward S. Herman
 

Search
Balkan
Witness

Last modified March 01, 2014


Reviews of The Politics of Genocide (by Edward S. Herman and David Peterson)

The politics of denialism: The strange case of Rwanda Review of The Politics of Genocide, by Edward Herman. This article focuses on Herman's denial of the Rwanda genocide, but Herman's approach to that issue is similar to his denial of the Serbian genocidal campaign in Bosnia and Serbia's attempted genocide in Kosovo. The author aptly dissects Herman's propensity for inverting the roles of perpetrators and victims. By Gerald Caplan, Pambazuka News, June 17, 2010
See also
° Sources and Testimonies - a Response to Herman and Peterson, by Gerald Caplan, July 16, 2010
° On Genocide Deniers - Challenging Herman and Peterson, by Adam Jones, July 16, 2010
° Srebrenica deniers get their mucky paws on Rwanda, by Marko Hoare, September 7, 2010
° "Left-wing" genocide denial, by Martin Shaw, The Journal of Genocide Research, June 2011   Why do they do it? The obvious answer is political: they have such a huge investment in the idea that the USA and the West are the source of all the world’s evils, that they can only process information to fit this case. More complex answers might include that they are building an intellectual and political niche out of contrarian positions. The danger is that such nonsense, with its pseudo-scholarly apparatus of extensive footnotes and media science, finds a ready audience among the political idealistic.

Naming the Genocide Deniers In a recent book, Herman repeats his denial of Bosnia and Rwanda genocides. By George Monbiot, June 13, 2011

Correspondence with Noam Chomsky, in which Chomsky shows himself to be incapable of responding to criticism that he endorsed Edward Herman and David Peterson's denial of the Bosnia and Rwanda genocides. By George Monbiot, June 2011

See No Evil How did genocide denial become a doctrine of the internationalist left? By George Monbiot, May 21, 2012

Genocide Denial: Expert Assessments Additional Critiques of The Politics of Genocide, by Adam Jones, Linda Malvern, Martin Shaw, and Marko Hoare. May 21, 2012

Once more on "left-wing" genocide denial Edward Herman and David Peterson, in their reply to George Monbiot, do little to respond to the wave of incredulity and revulsion which their denial of genocide and its endorsement by Noam Chomsky are causing. By Martin Shaw, May 22, 2012

What Motivates Edward Herman and the Balkan Revisionists? Why is he reflexively living out a Cold War paradigm, apologizing for those who have committed ethnic mass murder in the name of a shadow of socialism? By Roger Lippman, April 26, 2009

Why Yugoslavia Still Matters (Follow-up discussion here.) Edward Herman manages to construct an alternative universe in which Serbian military forces only acted in defense, Slobodan Milosevic was a benevolent Gorbachev figure, and the international legal community functioned as some kind of adjunct to NATO. The article critiques Herman's latest recitation of his usual themes. By John Feffer, Foreign Policy in Focus, April 6, 2009

The Dismantling of Yugoslavia Monthly Review does its readers a disservice in presenting Edward Herman and David Peterson's skewed version of the Yugoslav conflicts. The Serbian wars of conquest and genocide (attempted and partially accomplished) against other Yugoslav ethnic groups deserve a more nuanced analysis. At the very least, the MR issue could have presented a range of Left perspectives. Instead, the magazine discredits itself with its endorsement of two indefatigable propagandists who fantasize about Western plots to undermine Yugoslavia while downplaying the Serbian war crimes that have been broadly recognized and condemned in the world community. For example, on the tenth anniversary of the Srebrenica massacre of about 8000 Bosnian Muslims by Serbian forces, Herman and Peterson's "Srebrenica Research Group" called a press conference at the UN not to offer support for the survivors, but rather to deny the essential facts of the massacre. By Roger Lippman and Peter Lippman, December 2007

Srebrenica: Response to left-wing apologists for genocide The Srebrenica genocide has been actively denied by a coalition of people on the far right and left of the political spectrum. The apex of this campaign was the publication by Ed Herman, who now appears to work full time on such issues, of "The Politics of the Srebrenica Massacre." I will respond to the main allegations within it. By Michael Karadjis, November 11, 2007

The lists of missing at Srebrenica Of Edward Herman’s many dubious and outright false assertions about Srebrenica, one of the most contemptible is his attempt to make disappear from history the roughly 8000 Bosnian civilians massacred by Serbian forces. Some of his mystification is couched in slippery deniability, in a half-hearted attempt to deflect the criticism he deserves. But taken together, his comments comprise a clear endeavor at war-crimes denial. By Balkan Witness staff, August 2005

Edward Herman: The Politics of the Srebrenica Massacre On the occasion of the 10th anniversary of the Srebrenica massacre, Herman insulted the survivors with denials of Serbian atrocities and apologetics for Serbian aggression. Several readers responded. July 2005

Srebrenica and the London Bombings: The ‘Anti-War’ Link This article examines what unites the left-wing and right-wing deniers of Serbia's war crimes. Includes discussion of Edward Herman, Justin Raimondo, Nebojsa Malic, Neil Clark, Tariq Ali, and others. By Marko Hoare, July 23, 2005

The Left Revisionists An extensive review of a broad array of those on the Left who downplay the violence and suffering involved in the wars in the former Yugoslavia and shift the blame to the Western alliance. Among those discussed are Edward Herman, Noam Chomsky, Michael Parenti, Michel Chossudovsky, Diana Johnstone, Mick Hume, John Pilger, Harold Pinter, and Jared Israel. By Marko Hoare, November 2003

The Kosovo Verification Mission at Racak A summary of the events surrounding the Racak massacre and its investigation. Concisely refutes some of the inaccurate statements of Edward Herman, Diana Johnstone, Philip Hammond, and David Peterson. By Alex J. Bellamy, 2002

Mediating Denial Martin Shaw reviews Edward S. Herman and Phillip Hammond's anthology Degraded Capability: The Media and the Kosovo Crisis. Shaw analyzes distortions by Diana Johnstone, John Pilger, Mick Hume, and others. June 2000

More on Kosovo            More on Bosnia


Diana Johnstone
, whose work has been praised by Herman, and from whom he casually lifts many of the misrepresentations he repeats, has been critiqued in the articles below:

Diana Johnstone's Fools Crusade is reviewed by Kirk Johnson, 2006. Several installments, linked from the cited page.

Johnstone's article "Srebrenica Revisited," is reviewed by Eric Gordy, October 13, 2005.

Raçak - Mutation of a Massacre This review of a Diana Johnstone article shows that she uncritically repeats Serbian government propaganda on Racak, and that her work is characterized by missing evidence, a paucity of sources, the spreading of untruths, and conspiracy theories. By Peter Wuttke, November 18, 1999 (Newly translated from the original German, March 2002.)
 


Historical Background   Documents  Commentary   Non-violent Solutions  

Reports from the Area of Conflict   Kosovo Albanians in Serbian Prisons

Post-War Kosovo   Kosovo Independence

Bosnia    Post-War Bosnia

Post-War Serbia   On Serbian Nationalism

Croatia   Macedonia

Special compilation: the Racak Massacre

The Milosevic War-Crimes Trial

War-crimes Deniers    Srebrenica Debate
 

 


Balkan Witness Home Page


LETTERS from KOSOVO and BOSNIA, by PETER LIPPMAN

RELATED INFORMATIONAL SITES

VIDEO      BOOKS      MAPS

SEARCH BALKAN WITNESS

Contact Balkan Witness

Report broken links